Defining vs Non-Defining Relative Clauses
B2 Level
The difference between defining and non-defining relative
clauses is one of the most important grammar distinctions at B2 level.
Defining clauses identify which person or thing we mean — they are essential:
"The students who passed the exam celebrated" (only those who passed, not all students).
Non-defining clauses add extra information about something already identified —
they are not essential: "My mother, who is a nurse, works at the hospital" (I only have
one mother, so the clause just adds extra detail).
Three rules separate these two types. First, non-defining clauses always have commas; defining clauses never do. Second, you can use that in defining clauses ("The book that I read") but never in non-defining clauses ("The book, which I enjoyed" — not "that"). Third, you can remove a non-defining clause and the sentence still makes complete sense; removing a defining clause changes the meaning. Cambridge B2 exams test this contrast in open-cloze and sentence-transformation tasks, so mastering both types and their punctuation is essential for exam success.
Three rules separate these two types. First, non-defining clauses always have commas; defining clauses never do. Second, you can use that in defining clauses ("The book that I read") but never in non-defining clauses ("The book, which I enjoyed" — not "that"). Third, you can remove a non-defining clause and the sentence still makes complete sense; removing a defining clause changes the meaning. Cambridge B2 exams test this contrast in open-cloze and sentence-transformation tasks, so mastering both types and their punctuation is essential for exam success.
Quick Rule
defining: noun + who/which/that + clause (no commas) | non-defining: noun , + who/which + clause , (commas, no "that")
- 1.Students who didn't pass the exam must retake it. (defining — identifies which students, negative)
- 2.My brother, who lives in London, is visiting next week. (non-defining — extra information)
- 3.Paris, which is the capital of France, attracts millions of tourists. (non-defining — "that" not allowed)
- 4.The car that I bought last week has broken down already. (defining — "that" is fine)
- 5.Our teacher, who has taught here for twenty years, is retiring. (non-defining — commas required)
Continue Practising
Continue practising with these related exercises
-ed vs -ing Adjectives
EasyPractise bored/boring, interested/interesting, and other feeling adjective pairs
60 questions
Practise now
Conditionals
MediumMaster all types of conditional sentences (zero to third)
330 questions
Practise now
Present Perfect
MediumLearn to talk about experiences and unfinished time
240 questions
Practise now
Reported Speech
MediumTransform direct speech into indirect speech
290 questions
Practise now
Passive Voice
MediumChange the focus from doer to receiver of the action
120 questions
Practise now
Past Simple
EasyTalk about completed actions and events in the past
300 questions
Practise now